New Super Mario Bros. Wii - IGNau review

9.0 Presentation
It's Mario through and through - from the chunky menus and familiar HUD to the use of colour. Even the overworld maps offer strategy and challenge.
8.0 Graphics
Certainly simple but effective; NSMB Wii adheres to a traditional Mario design ethic, blending 2D and 3D with a minimum of flair and fuss, but always retaining clarity.
8.5 Sound
A great soundtrack that sets the dial to 'fun' and doesn't relent. The classic sound effects are a great and evocative nod to past Mario games, while Mario himself quips away gleefully.
9.5 Gameplay
Platforming has rarely been done better; NSMB Wii blends great course design with multiplayer --and it nails it. A true all-ages gaming experience that will still test your mettle and surprise you.
9.0 Lasting Appeal
The lack of score table and online hurts, but the eight worlds are large and bursting with secrets waiting to be found. The multiplayer is joyous and compelling. Domo, Nintendo.
9.2
Outstanding OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average) See All Award Recipients

link